Odd Pairings
Laurel and Hardy -
The Silent Years: 1927
Various directors for Hal Roach
USA 1927
Eureka Masters Of Cinema
We’ve always liked Laurel and Hardy in my house. When I was a kid growing up in the 1970s, the dynamic duo were on television regularly… until around the mid-1980s when legal wrangling from various studios and estates kept them off people’s TV sets for decades… but their shorts... their talkies... were on TV quite often before that and we used to watch them a lot. My dad even had a Super 8 projector in the loft with a few reels of Super 8 cut downs from their silent movies, which he used to say were possibly even funnier than their talkies.
So it was a welcome surprise when Eureka Masters Of Cinema released some of those early silents, the surviving movies from 1927, on Blu Ray disc towards the end of 2024 as a double disc set called Laurel and Hardy - The Silent Years: 1927. A perfect Christmas present for my dad and, over a number of weeks, we watched one a week in front of our family Friday night movie. The films included here are Lucky Dog, Duck Soup, Slipping Wives, Love ‘Em And Weep, Why Girls Love Sailors, With Love and Hisses, Sailors Beware, Do Detectives Think, Flying Elephants, Sugar Daddies, The Second Hundred Years, Call Of The Cuckoo, Putting Pants On Philip and The Battle Of The Century (which I think is one of the films that got remade by them as a talkie too).
Now, I will have to say from the top, something that Eureka perhaps should have mentioned on their packaging and marketing… although it’s quite obvious why they didn’t. And that is that, for the most part, while it’s true that Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy both feature in every short movie on these discs… they are rarely paired together and sometimes don’t really even meet much in the course of these stories (which, of course, all amount to extended, epic sketches, running around 20 minutes each). So, it’s not quite, until the very last two films maybe (with small exceptions), the boys reach their full on ‘Laurel and Hardy’ alter egos, for sure.
However, there is a lot of interest and entertainment to be had looking at the way these two actors evolved their characters and their on screen relationship together as the shorts went on. For instance, a lot of Stan Laurel’s trademarks such as the crying at the camera and the funny, legs akimbo jump he sometimes does are firmly there right from the get go, whatever character he’s playing. Similarly, Oliver Hardy’s facial expressions are very much the personae he inhabits more famously down the line, in most of these. And both of them, right from the get go, are constantly looking into the camera at the audience at appropriate moments and breaking the fourth wall… something else they used to do a lot in their double act. And there are a few times when they’re paired up and are brilliant together (Stan Laurel was obviously contributing to the content of these by this point) and you wonder why they are back in a different capacity in the next movie.
So in Duck Soup, for example… which was a lost film for years and helps underline the importance of restorations and releases like this… the regular routine is almost there. And, again, in Do Detectives Think?, the two are partnered up in exactly the kind so of situations they would find themselves in as a phenomenon in their own right. And asides from their circumstances, The Second Hundred Years seems not far from what they would become either. Now, most people say it wasn’t until Putting Pants on Phillip as to where everything came together but, that seems a little less like the pairing than those I just mentioned… although I think we can all agree that The Battle Of The Century, with its extended custard pie fight, is where everything comes together nicely for them. So it’s a little of a shame that its the last film to come within the boundaries of the title of this particular collection… although Eureka have already just released an equally limited edition set of their silent shorts from 1928 (yeah, I’m saving that one for a Father’s Day* present… it’s currently hidden in a stack of blu rays).
The set is sometimes funny, occasionally hilarious but almost always interesting. The restorations are all great and hard won with the only casualty, dammit, being a bridging sequence in The Battle Of The Century between the two main acts, which has been recreated by a few stills which promise more than they can deliver here, alas. And a shout out to fans of Abbott and Costello on that particular film. Look to Ollie’s left in the crowd of spectators at the boxing match and you will quite clearly see a young Lou Costello amongst the onlookers. We knew he was supposed to be in there and we thought we’d have a hard time spotting him but he’s using the same mannerisms for rowdy whistling he would use in his movies two decades later so, yeah, he’s easy to spot and it’s nice to see one half of one of the great double acts rubbing shoulders briefly with the greatest comedy double act of all time.
And that’s me done, I think on this one. If you are a fan of comedy cinema then Laurel and Hardy - The Silent Years: 1927 is an absolutely essential purchase for your library. I’m really pleased to have had the opportunity to see these and I am looking forward to the next set immensely.
* RIP Brian Michael Cox













